Skip to content
Sunday, Nov 22
AmericaStrikes
diplomacy
Analysis

Kim Holds the Next Move as Trump Calls Arms Limits Very Hard

Trump says nuclear arms limits with China and Russia will be very hard to achieve, while the SCMP argues Kim Jong-un now holds the next move on a meeting. What the summit left open.

Kim Holds the Next Move as Trump Calls Arms Limits Very Hard
Photo: YHBae / Pixabay · Pixabay License
By David MitchellDiplomacy correspondent·Published ·3 min read

The diplomacy that followed Donald Trump’s China trip rests on two judgments that point the same way: the next move on North Korea belongs to Pyongyang, and arms control with Beijing and Moscow will be hard. The South China Morning Post argues that the ball is in Kim Jong-un’s court on a meeting with Trump. Separately, Reuters reported that Trump says nuclear arms limits with China and Russia will be “very hard” to achieve.

This desk has the headlines and short summaries of both reports, not the full text. The analysis below is limited to what those headlines establish and what our earlier coverage already documented. Where we infer, we say so.

The Kim question

The SCMP framing places responsibility for the next step on Pyongyang. That is consistent with how the trip played out. Trump left China without meeting Kim, and the headline of that report settled only that no meeting occurred, not why.

The signals from North Korea during the visit were mixed. Kim criticized what he called “enemy” naval activity while Trump publicly called for a meeting, as we reported in Kim Jong Un Condemns Enemy Naval Activity as Trump Seeks a Meeting. We do not know which vessels or exercises Kim meant, and the material available to us does not include a North Korean response to the invitation itself.

If the SCMP reading is right, Washington has made its offer and Pyongyang sets the timing. The headline does not say what Kim might want in return, and we will not guess at terms.

Arms control looks harder than the summit imagery suggested

The Reuters headline is blunt: limits on nuclear arms involving China and Russia will be “very hard” to achieve, in Trump’s words. It does not say what formula Trump had in mind, whether he was describing a three-way treaty or separate talks, or what either government has offered.

The caution fits the broader record of the summit. A joint declaration involving China, Russia and the United States drew attention for what it omitted, as we covered in China, Russia and US Peace Declaration Omits Ukraine and Iran Wars. The President’s own assessment of the arms-control track now suggests that the gap between the optics of a three-leader meeting and substantive agreements remains wide.

A narrower area of agreement on AI

One topic did produce an upbeat line. Reuters reported that Trump says he and Xi Jinping want moderate rules on artificial intelligence. The summary does not say whether any text was agreed, which systems or uses would be covered, or whether Beijing has described its position the same way. It is a statement of intent by one side, not a deal.

The contrast is useful. Where interests are less tied to existing arsenals, leaders talk of moderation. Where they are tied to nuclear forces, Trump himself describes the path as difficult. That is our reading of two headlines, not a finding from either report.

Ukraine hangs over everything

The summit’s Ukraine dimension also remains unsettled. Yahoo reported that Trump called Putin “my friend” at the China summit amid the war. The Guardian’s briefing says Jared Kushner described Trump as “open” to a NATO-like mutual defence guarantee for Kyiv. Both are headline-level items for this desk.

Moscow’s answer arrived in a different form. Russia launched a mass missile attack on Ukraine after Putin vowed revenge, and earlier Putin rejected a limited ceasefire following a strike on the Crimean bridge. Those events complicate any claim that personal rapport translated into movement on the war.

Zelenskyy, for his part, has told the major powers how he believes the war could end, according to The Kyiv Independent. The summary available to us does not give the specifics. His earlier position is in Zelenskyy Says Trump and Xi Could Pressure Putin on Ukraine War.

What to watch

  1. Any public response from Pyongyang. The SCMP argument depends on Kim choosing to act. Nothing in the items we reviewed shows that he has.
  2. Whether Washington defines its arms-control approach. Trump’s “very hard” assessment does not indicate whether talks with China and Russia will start in any form.
  3. Whether the AI statement becomes text. Without a draft or a Chinese confirmation, “moderate rules” remains a stated preference.
  4. Whether security guarantees for Ukraine are specified. “Open” is not a commitment, and Russia’s latest strikes suggest Moscow is not signaling restraint.

We will update this analysis as the outlets cited above and the governments involved provide more detail.

Found this useful? Share it.

More on diplomacy

Related reporting

More stories from this beat.

  1. Zelenskyy Says He Urged Trump to Enlist China in Ukraine Peace Push

    Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy disclosed he pressed Donald Trump to bring Beijing's influence to bear on Moscow as diplomatic activity around the war intensifies.

    Read story →
  2. Putin Rules Out Limited Ceasefire With Ukraine After Bridge Strike

    CBS News reports Putin says Russia will not negotiate a limited ceasefire with Ukraine after the bridge strike, as Trump says a nuclear arms deal with Moscow and Beijing will be hard.

    Read story →
  3. Trump Says Ceasefire Holds Despite New Russian Strikes

    Trump says Russia and Ukraine agreed to halt strikes on energy sites, but Kyiv reports fresh attacks and Zelenskyy says the deal is 'news to me.'

    Read story →