Skip to content
Tuesday, Nov 17
AmericaStrikes
diplomacy
Analysis

Ukraine Talks Widened This Week. The Positions Did Not Move Closer.

Envoys saw Putin, Europe got a promised seat and a Trump-Putin meeting is set for Shenzhen. But Washington's land-for-NATO idea and Moscow's NATO retrenchment demand point in opposite directions.

Ukraine Talks Widened This Week. The Positions Did Not Move Closer.
Photo: gdmoonkiller / Pixabay · Pixabay License
By David MitchellDiplomacy correspondent·Published ·5 min read

Thesis: the diplomacy around the Ukraine war got bigger this week, with more participants, more channels and a scheduled leader meeting. The substance did not get closer. The one concrete trade that surfaced, Ukrainian NATO membership in exchange for the Donbas, runs against the main demand Moscow restated the same week, which is that NATO pull back. This desk’s reading is that the process widened because the underlying gap is wide. The facts below come from the reporting cited. The interpretation is ours and is labeled as such.

What changed on the process side

On Thursday, U.S. envoys Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff met Putin at the Kremlin, per CBC. The summary of that report did not say what was discussed or whether anything was agreed. Zelensky called the visit a “window of opportunity,” according to EA WorldView’s Day 1,722 account.

The same day, a U.S. envoy said Putin agreed to let European representatives join the next round of talks, per Defense News. The envoy was not named in the summary, and the claim came from the American side, not from Moscow or from European capitals. Kremlin aide Yuri Ushakov separately said Trump and Putin will “continue to discuss the full range of issues related to the settlement” at the APEC summit in Shenzhen, the Kyiv Independent reported. No date or agenda has been published.

Zelensky then met the envoys in Dublin and said it makes sense for Europeans to be involved, pointing to Ukraine’s hope of joining the EU, the BBC reported.

That is three new elements in two days: a Kremlin meeting, a promised European seat and a leader-level meeting on the calendar. None of them has a published text behind it.

What Moscow said it wants

The Kremlin’s public line moved the other way. The Kyiv Post reported that Putin rejected peacekeepers in Ukraine and revived NATO demands. A report carried by Türkiye Today said Russia is seeking Finland’s exit from NATO and a ban on military bases in the Baltic region as part of the talks. That report did not identify its original source, so treat it as unconfirmed.

Later Friday the New York Times reported that Russia has revived a demand that NATO retrench as a condition for a deal. Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty ran an explainer asking why Russia’s demands are a big barrier to a settlement. Our material has only its headline, so we do not describe its contents.

On territory, the Atlantic Council reported that Putin’s chief negotiator vowed to return “every inch of Russian land” in Ukraine, per the headline. The summary did not say which territory he meant.

The accounts do not establish whether the Kyiv Post, Türkiye Today and New York Times items describe one statement or several. They do agree on direction. Moscow is tying a settlement to the alliance’s posture and to the Baltic and Nordic flank, not only to the front line in Ukraine.

What Washington reportedly floated

On Saturday Zelensky said U.S. envoys asked for the first time whether Kyiv would withdraw from the Donbas in exchange for a NATO bid, the BBC and Al Jazeera reported. He said Kyiv would not retreat from its territory. The Jerusalem Post reported he would nonetheless put the question to a referendum if Ukraine received a full security package.

By Sunday, headlines carried a blunter version. Newser summarized his answer as “No way,” and the Guardian’s war briefing described the U.S. proposal as Kyiv giving up land for a path into the alliance, on Zelensky’s account, per our Sunday report. Separately, la Repubblica carried a headline quoting Kushner saying “NATO will remain a cornerstone of European security.” The summary did not give the setting, so we do not read it as a comment on the land question.

One caveat matters for everything in this section. Every account of the proposal traces to Zelensky. We have seen no White House or State Department statement confirming the terms, whether it was written, or whether it was a formal offer or an exploratory question.

Where the positions collide

This is interpretation, built on the facts above.

First, the trade is internally contradictory against Moscow’s stated terms. If Washington offered Kyiv a NATO bid for the Donbas, it was offering something Moscow’s reported demands would reject. Russia is reportedly asking for Finland to leave the alliance and for base bans in the Baltic, which is a far larger ask than blocking Ukraine. A Ukrainian membership path would run against that, and NATO membership decisions need the agreement of the alliance’s members in any case, as our Sunday report noted. Nothing in the reporting shows that members have agreed to offer it.

Second, the referendum condition shifts the burden. Zelensky tied a public vote to a “full security package.” The reporting does not say what that package would contain. Until Washington and NATO capitals define it, Kyiv has no basis to call a vote, and until Moscow drops the peacekeeper objection, any package that relies on foreign troops looks blocked.

Third, adding Europeans to the table raises the number of parties who must accept a territorial trade without lowering the difficulty of the trade. Zelensky welcomed it for a direct reason: Ukraine wants EU membership and European capitals will help pay for and enforce whatever is agreed. The same logic gives Finland and the Baltic states a stake in the NATO-retrenchment question, and the reporting so far includes no reaction from them.

Our view is that the three-way structure explains the week’s pattern. Washington talks to Moscow about the settlement, then to Kyiv about the price, and the two conversations are producing incompatible asks.

The pressure track runs beside it

Fighting and sanctions did not pause. The UK sanctioned Russia’s Slavneft and says it is the first country to target all of Russia’s top 10 oil producers, per Reuters and the Kyiv Independent. The EU plans to present a new Russia sanctions package and Ukraine funding measures by year-end, according to Reuters.

Reuters, citing the International Energy Agency, also reported that Russian fuel exports and oil output rebounded in October after a deal with Trump, and that the world oil market is returning to surplus as Gulf exports recover. A looser market reduces the leverage any supply disruption gives, though the reporting does not draw that link. For the Gulf side, see our Brent report.

On the ground, Ukraine’s General Staff reported strikes on a Samara oil station and a Russian airbase, while Russian attacks continued, including a Volgograd drone strike that killed four and the reported hit on a Kyiv hospital. Ukraine is also racing to repair power plants before winter.

Indicators for the coming week

  1. A U.S. readout. A White House or State Department statement confirming or disputing Zelensky’s account would settle whether land-for-NATO was a real offer.
  2. Names for the European seat. A list of governments and a date would turn a claim by one envoy into a process.
  3. The Kremlin’s response to the Donbas-for-NATO formula. Silence is a signal. A flat rejection tied to the retrenchment demand would confirm the collision described above.
  4. A date for Shenzhen. The White House has not confirmed a Trump-Putin meeting. See also our report on the planned China summit with Xi.
  5. Finland and the Baltic states. A statement from Helsinki or the Baltic capitals on the reported demands would show how far the NATO question has spread beyond Ukraine.

What would change this read: a published framework from any party, or a Kremlin statement that drops the NATO conditions. Without either, the week’s activity is more people at the table, not agreement on what is being traded.

Found this useful? Share it.